“Encontré dos leyes contradictorias en su sitio. En una se establece que si un hombre comete adulterio con la esposa de otro, debe ser asesinado, mientras que en la otra se dice que esto es permitido y no se requiere venganza. ¿Cuál es la correcta? ¿Por qué están diciendo cosas contradictorias? ¿En qué debemos creer?””- I will not answer any more questions, I have already read all the questions related to this topic on your website. I also read about the issue of Lian. In fact, a friend said at that time that anyone could kill their wife according to their own criteria, why do we need 4 witnesses? Furthermore, he said that punishments should be imposed by the government, and I have not seen a satisfactory response from you about it.””Estás diciendo que se necesita un testigo, no está permitido matar, pero en la misma fatwa se menciona que los imanes de las 4 escuelas permiten el asesinato. Pregunto sobre esta contradicción.””Estás afirmando que se requiere un testigo, que no está permitido matar, pero en la misma fatwa se menciona que los imanes de las 4 escuelas permiten el asesinato. Pregunto acerca de esta contradicción.””- It is not permitted for someone who knows for sure that their wife or daughter is living in an illegitimate relationship, to try to kill her or make her be killed. A man asked the Prophet (Peace and blessings be upon him) the following:””¿What do you think if I come home and see my husband committing adultery with another man and I kill him?” “I need four male witnesses.” “And if I can’t find them?” “Then I will apply the law of retaliation.””Si un hombre entra en su casa y encuentra a su esposa o a una mujer con la que tiene una relación íntima cometiendo adulterio, y él la mata, esto es permitido para él y no se necesita venganza en su contra.””Esto también es la opinión de los Hanbelí, Shafi’i y Malikíes.””- If a woman commits adultery of her own will, according to the Hanafi and Hanbali schools, the husband can kill both of them.”
“Dear brother/sister,”
“First of all, it must be made clear that when a person commits adultery and their wife witnesses it, there are two aspects to killing their wife and the person with whom they committed adultery: one in terms of judgment in the afterlife, and the other in terms of judgment in this world.”
“Sin embargo, from the point of view of world law, the person who kills their spouse while committing adultery must prove it, otherwise, that person who cannot prove it will be sentenced to death.”
“Se evalúa si la persona está en lo correcto o no, y se toma una decisión basada en la presencia de testigos.”
“Here, two different sentences have been issued, depending on whether the person who claims to have killed his wife while she was committing adultery can prove it or not.”
“When detailing:”
“- In Islam, four witnesses are required to establish adultery. However, this only applies in cases where the action is carried out.”
“Las traducciones de los versículos relevantes son las siguientes:”
“De estos versos, se puede entender que en lo que respecta a la persona que presencia a su esposa cometiendo adulterio y la situación de su esposa, hay varias narraciones sobre la razón de la revelación de los versos anteriores. En este sentido, el testimonio del esposo se considera como cuatro testigos, y la mujer puede salvarse del castigo tomando el juramento de Lian”.
“Aquí hay dos opiniones de expertos:”
“According to legend, the venerable Ali, who was faced with a question about this topic, said the following:”
“Summary”
“According to legend, one day while the Prophet Omar was having breakfast, a man ran towards him with a blood-stained sword in his hand and sat down next to him. Then, a group of people ran after him and asked for Omar. The man responded with his sword in hand and pointed towards his two legs.”
“After this, the Prophet Omar (addressing the men of the murdered man) asked: What happened? The men responded: He (the victim) attacked us. Then Prophet Omar took the man’s sword and shook it a bit before returning it to him, and he added: If you see your wife in a situation like this again, you can kill her again.”
“En relación a esto, no hay ninguna diferencia entre el juicio de Hz. Ömer y el de Hz. Ali. Algunos han caído en el error de creer que hay una contradicción entre estos juicios debido a una evaluación superficial. La verdad es la siguiente:”
“The ruling issued by Hz. Ali is based on the following legal rule: If a man sees his wife committing adultery with another man, but cannot present four witnesses and decides to kill the man, then his cat will be executed in his place (since, according to the relevant verses of Sura Nur, the only solution in this case is mutual cursing (Lian). Killing the man without resorting to this goes against these verses).”
“En la sentencia dictada por el honorable Ömer, la principal razón por la cual se permite matar a alguien acusado de adulterio es, de hecho, la siguiente regla aceptada por nuestros compañeros:”
“Uno de los famosos eruditos de los Hanbalis ha proporcionado la información anterior y ha citado la fatwa relevante de Hz. Ömer, y luego, basándose en la fatwa de Hz. Ali, ha adoptado su veredicto. Además, ha añadido”
Greetings and prayers…Saludos y oraciones…”Preguntas sobre el Islam”
